Euston HS2 mission prices rise to over £7.5bn

Unlock Editor's Digest without cost

Roula Khalaf, editor-in-chief of the FT, selects her favourite tales on this weekly e-newsletter.

The price of transporting the Excessive Pace ​​2 rail hyperlink to London's Euston and constructing a brand new station on the location was greater than £7.5 billion, authorities paperwork present confidential paperwork that shed new mild on the spiraling prices of the mission.

In the beginning of 2023, the Nationwide Audit Workplace virtually doubled its price estimate, to £4.8 billion, for the brand new mission. HS2 Euston station solely – excluding different components of the mission together with tunnels and the redevelopment of the prevailing station.

However a doc drawn up by the Division for Transport later in 2023, marked “official – delicate: industrial” particulars the total price of the HS2 Euston mission for the primary time.

The DfT doc estimates the worth of the brand new HS2 station and tunnels at £6 billion. One other NAO report printed earlier this yr urged an extra £1.5 billion is required to rebuild close by Euston station, bringing the overall price to £7.5 billion.

The DfT's estimates for the price of the complete Euston mission are based mostly on 2019 costs – the quantity is now nearer to £9.4 billion after accounting for inflation, in accordance with Monetary calculations Occasions.

The query of how you can fund Euston poses a political problem for the federal government. It’s struggling to keep costs low on the general HS2 mission linking London and Birmingham, estimated at £67 billion however which is anticipated to be revised upwards within the coming months.

Tony Travers, a public coverage knowledgeable on the London College of Economics, stated the Euston mission's prices had turn out to be uncontrollable since work started in 2017.

He stated: “It’s extraordinary – and never in a great way – that the mission may demolish folks's properties and undermine native companies, thereby appropriating the encircling setting, and that nearly a decade later, there’s nonetheless no clear plan or funds. for such a strategically situated website in one of many richest cities on this planet.

Former Conservative Prime Minister Rishi Sunak introduced in October 2023 that he was canceling the northern a part of HS2 from Birmingham to Manchester, citing price causes.

On the similar time, he gave the inexperienced mild to the redevelopment of Euston, saying a brand new public-private partnership which he hoped would save taxpayers £6.5 billion from the Euston mission.

DfT paperwork seem to contradict this declare, suggesting such a partnership would produce “rather more modest financial savings” of between £1.4 billion and £2 billion.

The Sunak authorities's declare that £6.5 billion may very well be raised from the personal sector “was fairly far-fetched, it was exhausting to seek out anybody who believed that on the time”, a authorities official stated.

Travers stated: “Even a major property growth in Euston. . . would – within the context of the ultimate price of HS2 – produce solely a small sum of money.

Sunak additionally claimed on the time that 10,000 properties may very well be constructed on the location, however DfT paperwork point out that Lendlease, the federal government's accomplice for growth above and across the station, is planning a decrease variety of 2 000 to three,000 flats.

In principle, 8,000 flats may very well be constructed, however provided that the complete website was used for residential functions, which might make it much less commercially viable, in accordance with the paperwork.

A Sunak ally stated it was the DfT which put ahead the estimates of £6.5 billion in financial savings and 10,000 properties. “The correct course of was adopted and the figures given have been offered by the ministries,” he stated.

The paperwork point out that coming into into a brand new public-private settlement on the website would require renegotiating the prevailing contract with Lendlease.

Andrea Ruckstuhl, group director at Lendlease, stated the developer plans to “ship new buildings and public areas in Euston by a planning software and partnerships with buyers”.

Euston is overcrowded and struggling to accommodate 33 million passengers a yr, in comparison with 20 million passengers when it was final revamped in 1968. The anticipated inflow of passengers from HS2 will add to stress on the station.

Greater than £2 billion was spent on the Euston mission, in accordance with a 2022 Nationwide Audit Workplace report.

The DfT stated it might not touch upon the leaked paperwork, however didn’t deny the figures.

“Bringing HS2 to Euston is a key a part of realizing HS2's contribution to nationwide financial development, which is why this Authorities has confirmed funding for the Previous Oak Frequent Tunnel in Euston within the Funds,” he stated. declared. “We’re working across the clock to discover a variety of choices for Euston, together with funding, and can set out extra particulars in the end.”