U.S. accounting qualification reforms spark trade battle

Keep knowledgeable with free updates

Merely register at Accounting myFT Digest – delivered straight to your inbox.

A proposed reform of the foundations for acquiring accounting {qualifications} in the USA may expose corporations to lawsuits for discrimination and add boundaries to entry to the occupation, in line with the group representing the biggest accounting corporations audit of the nation.

In a non-public remark letter seen by the Monetary Occasions, the Middle for Audit High quality – which represents the Large 4 and different massive corporations – condemned the proposed reforms as “unnecessarily advanced” and stated they may “introduce unconscious bias” within the qualification course of.

The CAQ’s intervention places massive auditing corporations at odds with two organizations that set up guidelines on the best way to receive the chartered accountant designation — the American Institute of CPAs and the Nationwide Affiliation of State Boards of Accountancy — on the best way to stem the decline of recent hires.

The AICPA and Nasba proposed in September to drop the requirement that accountants full the equal of 5 years of faculty, yet one more than a standard undergraduate diploma, a rule that has been accused of dissuading younger individuals from coming into the occupation.

The 2 organizations proposed an alternate path to qualification: changing the fifth yr of examine with a requirement for a yr of on-the-job coaching, which ought to certify {that a} recruit has acquired dozens of technical {and professional} expertise specified.

Liz Barentzen, vice-president of the CAQ, wrote in a remark letter submitted final month that the framework’s “lengthy listing of competencies, efficiency indicators and evaluation necessities creates an unnecessarily advanced system that could possibly be troublesome to implement constantly throughout jurisdictions.

And he or she added: “Qualitative evaluation frameworks can introduce subjectivity and unconscious bias into evaluation processes, doubtlessly creating employment-related points (e.g. allegations of discrimination) that might not in any other case exist. in any other case. »

The scarcity of accountants is beginning to emerge as a threat think about some corporations’ monetary reporting, and a few smaller accounting corporations have pulled again from area of interest companies reminiscent of auditing native governments. Business leaders have warned that enormous corporations may have issue recruiting if tendencies don’t reverse shortly.

The variety of individuals taking the CPA examination has fallen from a excessive of greater than 100,000 in 2016 to a 17-year low of simply above 67,000 in 2022 and, after a slight uptick final yr, the AICPA predicts its decline will resume. within the brief time period. The variety of younger individuals taking accounting programs in school has declined in recent times, as they transfer towards better-paying entry-level jobs in finance or know-how.

The CAQ maintains that to treatment this scarcity, we should enhance the enchantment of accounting to college students from various backgrounds, for whom the bills related to a fifth yr of college might be notably problematic.

The AICPA and Nasba have dedicated to creating public feedback on their proposals in early 2025.

Sue Coffey, the AICPA’s government director of public accounting, stated she was “receiving useful and various suggestions” on her proposals.

“It’s important that licensure pathways are clear and compelling for college students. Working with Nasba and numerous stakeholders, we are going to know extra over the following month about what that appears like,” she stated.